WebClient vs HttpClient vs HttpWebRequest

http://www.diogonunes.com/blog/webclient-vs-httpclient-vs-httpwebrequest/

Just when I was starting to get used to call WebServices through WSDL – like I showed hereand here – I had to call a RESTful API. If you don’t know what I’m talking about you’re like me a week ago. Let’s just say that:

  • a WSDL API uses SOAP to exchange XML-encoded data
  • a REST API uses HTTP to exchange JSON-encoded data

That’s a whole new paradigm. Instead of GetObject() and SetObject() methods you have a single url api/object that may receive either an HTTP GET request or an HTTP POST request.

The .NET framework offers you three different classes to consume REST APIs: HttpWebRequest,WebClient, HttpClient. To worsen your analysis paralysis the open-source community created yet another library called RestSharp. Fear not, I’ll ease your choice.

In the beginning there was… HttpWebRequest

d41339a1ca4823cf39fa29453d41d073186851f2a09f0b07513024e1af43ebc8

This is the standard class that the .NET creators originally developed to consume HTTP requests. Using HttpWebRequest gives you control over every aspect of the request/response object, like timeouts, cookies, headers, protocols. Another great thing is that HttpWebRequestclass does not block the user interface thread. For instance, while you’re downloading a big file from a sluggish API server, your application’s UI will remain responsive.

However, with great power comes great complexity. In order to make a simple GET you need at least five lines of code; we’ll see WebClient does it in two.

HttpWebRequest http = (HttpWebRequest)WebRequest.Create("http://example.com");
WebResponse response = http.GetResponse();

MemoryStream stream = response.GetResponseStream();
StreamReader sr = new StreamReader(stream);
string content = sr.ReadToEnd();

The number of ways you can make a mistake with HttpWebRequest is truly astounding. Only useHttpWebRequest if you require the additional low-level control that it offers.

WebClient. Simple.

for_dummies_plain

WebClient is a higher-level abstraction built on top of HttpWebRequest to simplify the most common tasks. Using WebClient is potentially slower (on the order of a few milliseconds) than using HttpWebRequest directly. But that “inefficiency” comes with huge benefits: it requires less code, is easier to use, and you’re less likely to make a mistake when using it. That same request example is now as simple as:

var client = new WebClient();
var text = client.DownloadString("http://example.com/page.html");

Note: the using statements from both examples were omitted for brevity. You should definitely dispose your web request objects properly.

Don’t worry, you can still specify timeouts, just make sure you follow this workaround.

HttpClient, the best of both worlds

httpclient

HttpClient provides powerful functionality with better syntax support for newer threading features, e.g. it supports the await keyword. It also enables threaded downloads of files with better compiler checking and code validation. For a complete listing of the advantages and features of this class make sure you read this SO answer.

The only downfall is that it requires .NET Framework 4.5, which many older or legacy machines might not have.

Wait, a new contestant has appeared!

RestSharp_logo

Since HttpClient is only available for the .NET 4.5 platform the community developed an alternative. Today, RestSharp is one of the only options for a portable, multi-platform, unencumbered, fully open-source HTTP client that you can use in all of your applications.

It combines the control of HttpWebRequest with the simplicity of WebClient.

Conclusion

  • HttpWebRequest for control
  • WebClient for simplicity and brevity
  • RestSharp for both on non-.NET 4.5 environments
  • HttpClient for both + async features on .NET 4.5 environments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s